Leadership Matters
The House and Senate were back in D.C. last week, but it wasn’t business-as-usual. Republicans are still grieving major losses across the nation and coming to grips with entering a new year in the minority. While being in the minority often produces a more unified effort, who leads those minorities is instrumental in slowing down the agenda of the majority and laying the groundwork for the next election in two years. House and Senate Republicans had differing views on what needed to happen with their leadership.
In October 2023, under the Biden administration, House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) was ousted by his own party over differences in priorities. There were several contenders, but the Republican caucus was deeply divided over who should take the lead. After a 22-day fight, Representative Mike Johnson (R-LA) stepped into the race. He was the underdog that no one suspected. He had no previous committee chairmanships or positions in leadership. The only significant position on his resume was Chair of the Republican Study Committee (RSC) — the caucus that advocates for conservative legislation and solutions — for two years. The Republican caucus took three private votes, and Rep. Johnson earned the majority of the votes each time. After going to the floor for an official vote, Rep. Johnson received support from 100% of the Republicans, and he became Speaker of the House.
Speaker Johnson is an upstanding leader who is open about his faith and puts Christ at the center of his decisions. He navigated the Biden administration, a Democrat-led Senate, and then a Republican trifecta in the House, Senate, and White House. Even then, Johnson faced challenges from a very narrow majority, balancing the competing agendas from the Senate and White House, and corralling moderate members to support more conservative legislation. Despite the glaring obstacles, Speaker Johnson delivered for American families by orchestrating passage of the One Big, Beautiful Bill that contained tax cuts and a one-year defunding of Planned Parenthood, protected women in sports, prevented violent crimes from illegal aliens through the Laken Riley Act (becoming the first bill of Congress to become law), repealed numerous overreaching regulations, cut reckless spending, and passed the SAVE Act numerous times. Eagle Forum gave him an Eagle Award for his excellence in leadership. To read a more comprehensive list of Speaker Johnson’s accomplishments, check out former Congressional staffer Dan Ziegler’s reflection on the Speaker’s three years of stewardship.
After the midterm elections, Speaker Johnson announced he would not run for the minority leader position. In a Fox News interview, Speaker Johnson said:
We don’t like the results. But, real leadership, I’ve always believed, you lead from the front, and leaders have to take responsibility when things go wrong whether it’s individually deserved or not, that’s part of it …
In our view, the Speaker was the best person for the job at the time, and the election results were not a direct response to his leadership. However, he recognized that leading the minority should be handed off to someone else. Last week, leadership races were held with House Judiciary Chairman Jim Jordan (R-OH) and Majority Leader Steve Scalise (R-LA) competing for the top position. Rep. Jordan received the most votes, securing his role as House Minority Leader beginning next year.
Eagle Forum endorsed Chairman Jordan because of his expertise in judicial lawfare. Democrats intend to investigate and impeach members of President Trump’s family, Cabinet members, and other figures of the administration. Rep. Jordan has previously been a member of the House Freedom Caucus, is solidly pro-life, has advocated for strong borders, and has a long record of moving forward pro-family legislation. He previously ran for Speaker or Minority Leader three separate times, and the fourth time was a charm.
Whip Tom Emmer (R-MN) and House Conference Chair Lisa McClain (R-MI) were re-elected to serve in their key roles of whipping votes and communicating the top priorities of the Republican conference. Speaker Johnson congratulated the newly elected leadership team by saying:
I congratulate Reps. Jordan, Emmer, McClain, and the entire House GOP Leadership team on their elections to lead our Conference in the 120th Congress. It is a great honor to be called upon by your colleagues to serve, and these men and women are well-equipped to stand in the gap and preserve the values that have made America the freest, most powerful, and most successful nation the world has ever known. While we face challenges ahead, they are by no means insurmountable, and I look forward to working alongside this leadership team to earn back our majority and fight to preserve this grand experiment in self-governance.
Senate Republicans held their leadership elections shortly after the devastating election despite calls to wait until after all the Senate races were officially decided and an agenda for the future could be presented to the caucus. Sens. Ron Johnson (R-WI) and Mike Lee (R-UT) requested that the elections be held off for a few more weeks, but their request fell on deaf ears. Sen. Thune was quickly re-elected to the top Republican position, Minority Leader of the Senate, after Republicans lost nine Senate seats in the midterm elections. In addition, Sen. John Barrasso (R-WY) was re-elected as Minority Whip, and Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR) was re-elected as Republican Conference Chairman.
A lot of blame has been placed on the Senate Republicans for the lack of fight on issues that motivate American voters. They were never able to obtain the votes to pass legislation to protect women in sports, defund Planned Parenthood for longer than a year, stop sex changes on children, or pass the SAVE Act. They also allowed unregulated intoxicating hemp products to stay on shelves for another month.
Senate Minority Leader-elect Thune said in a Fox News interview he wants to connect with the “middle of the electorate” and independents. While we need many of them to ensure a Republican majority again, we hope that he and other Senate Republicans are strategic enough to educate that electorate without compromising conservative values. Sen. Thune must learn from his mistakes. Maintaining the status quo is no way to begin the 120th Congress.
Democrat leadership races have been more contentious. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries faces pushback from the more extreme members of the Democrat caucus who claim he is too pro-Israel. Jeffries has often taken a position unpopular with some in his caucus by denouncing antisemitism.  He has also been advocating for Palestine’s independent statehood.
The radicals in the Democratic majority demanded a roll call vote rather than a voice vote to show their defection, but in the end, Jeffries won 255 of the votes, setting him up to be the first Black Speaker. (The full House of Representatives will formally elect the Speaker in January.) Only seven Democrats (deemed “The Stubborn Seven”) voted against him. Jeffries will likely be the most liberal Speaker of the House with the agenda of pushing for expanded government healthcare, abortion-on-demand, amnesty for all illegal immigrants, and investigations into the Trump administration.
Senate Democrat leadership races are scheduled at the beginning of December. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) faces challenger Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD). Progressives are backing Van Hollen, but Schumer still has the lead. Leader Schumer has been known to fold at the last minute and strike deals with Republicans. However, his priorities are similar to Speaker-elect Jeffries, including legalizing recreational marijuana and abortion-on-demand until birth.
Eagle Forum will continue to work with members of Congress to fight against the Democrats’ extreme agenda. In the new Congress, you will likely see many more alerts in your inbox asking you to make your voice heard. We can expect the liberal majority to advance legislation that harms the family, life, and free markets. Make sure you are signed up for our emails here and follow us on all social media platforms.
Share this:
- Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
- Share on X (Opens in new window) X
- Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
- More
- Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
- Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
- Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
- Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
- Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
- Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
- Print (Opens in new window) Print





























